Welcome to the 'New Somerset and Dorset Railway'
Our Aim:
Thursday, January 10, 2008
authenticity
I've been digitalizing more of my early photos (above are 1972).
These are two shots on the Winchester-Alton route. I feel these capture the day-to-day reality of a run down branch line (in horrible weather). Can today's Watercress Line even begin to compete with this for atmosphere? What is preservation actually about? Do any of today's lines recreate the past as it really was, or is there so much pressure (and vested special interest groups) that every 'heritage' railway resembles little more than a full size train set with bits and pieces from different eras forced together, everything bright and shiny with beaming staff? That's been my experience and that was something we really hoped to avoid at the S&D. It may be an impossible aim. I suspect however that the more today's heritage railways morph into genuine community railways in an oil-less future then the more the atmosphere will return. Authenticity is everything if you think about it ...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
As an active member of an heritage railway and having previously commented anonymously I would like to now comment here.
Try visiting any major heritage railway in the early mornings or late evenings when there are no crowds of passengers and really appreciate the atmosphere of a bygone age. If you want run-down stations with run-down staff then go to the smaller heritage railways which unsurprisingly do not attract many passengers.
Today would passengers expect to wait at a run-down unstaffed halt with boarded up windows and paint peeled walls. Maybe the public of 1972 excepted it but today an average of 95% of passengers to a heritage railway are the average families and expect high standards. If not then passengers do not come back.
Finally if long established heritage stations are not maintained then they will become like your photo of 1972.
Members of the S & D are on a long steep learning curve when you become an operating railway. It is easy to criticise..!
From a working member of a heritage railway.
Post a Comment