Welcome to the 'New Somerset and Dorset Railway'
Our Aim:
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
melvyn, melvyn ...
So how did Melvyn Bragg's little railway programme go?
Much as expected. Lashings of patronising nostalgia, Pete Waterman, missing the point and some excellent archive film.
And two big mistakes, one of fact and one of opportunity.
Sheringham station was NOT closed by Beeching. Sheringham station remains part of the network on a branch from Norwich. True the NNR have acquired the original Sheringham station, but ownership was transferred by BR. The station was not closed!
And the piece where he interviewed the campaigner who fought for the Waverley route ... why didn't Melvyn make the point that the protestors were RIGHT, and that this essential Borders rail link is now being rebuilt, even if (for now) only as far as Tweedbank, which is almost Hawick where the film was shot?
Nostalgia ... your crimes are legion!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Looking at your photo provided with todays entry, I can't help it morphing in my mind to become Westgate Street in Bath, which has always been something of a "benchmark challenge" for the various doomed tramp proposals.
Your picture does show rather well how it would be experienced if "along the street running" was allowed. Even though the architecture is rather different when I put my reading glasses on !
It is of course the Aigle-Leysin line in Switzerland, making its way (against the one way traffic) down one of the narrow roads in Aigle. One train in each direction every hour, for 18 hours a day. Go along a few blocks and the trains of the Aigle-Sepey-Diablerets line doa similar stretch of street running for a mile or so, before taking to the mountains.
The picture was taken about three weeks ago, little has changed since my first visit in 1976! Shame about the GWR livery ...
If you get the chance visit the Mollibahn in Bad Doberan, eastern Germany, where this is all done by steam on an equally narrow road with a similar service but much longer trains!
Post a Comment